Contractor Red Flags to Avoid
Watch out for these common warning signs when hiring a roofer in Northwest Florida. Protect your investment from storm chasers.
Help protect your neighborhood!
After a storm, out-of-state contractors flood our area. Share this guide with your community to help your neighbors avoid roofing scams and poor workmanship.
Protecting Your Home from "Storm Chasers"
After a major storm, Northwest Florida is often flooded with out-of-state contractors looking for quick insurance payouts. While some are legitimate, many are "storm chasers" who do sub-par work, use cheap materials, and disappear long before warranty issues arise. Your roof is your home's primary defense—who you hire matters.
The Florida panhandle is one of the most targeted regions in the country for post-storm contractor fraud. After hurricanes and tropical systems sweep through Pensacola, Gulf Breeze, Navarre, and Milton, trucks with out-of-state license plates roll in within days. They knock on doors, promise the world, collect insurance checks, and leave behind leaky roofs, invalid warranties, and homeowners with no recourse. This guide gives you the exact warning signs to watch for—and the steps to verify any contractor before you sign a single document.
The 10 Biggest Red Flags
1. The "We'll Cover Your Deductible" Scam
If a contractor offers to waive, cover, or "absorb" your insurance deductible, walk away immediately. In Florida, this is considered insurance fraud and is a third-degree felony under Florida Statute 817.234. If they are willing to defraud the insurance company, they are likely cutting corners on your roof installation, too—and inflating the invoice to hide the deductible is the same crime.
2. No Local Physical Address
Check their license plates and Google their business address. If they are operating out of a PO Box, a hotel, a storage unit, or have out-of-state plates, they won't be around to answer the phone when your roof leaks two years from now. A true local company has roots in the community and a real office you can visit.
3. High-Pressure "Sign Now" Tactics
"This discount is only good if you sign today." Reputable roofers do not use high-pressure, door-to-door sales tactics. A professional contractor will provide a detailed, written estimate and give you the time you need to review it and make an educated decision. Any "today only" deal tied to a storm is a sales trap, not a benefit.
4. Demanding Full Payment Upfront
While a small deposit to schedule the job is standard, you should never pay for the entire roof upfront. Florida law limits what a contractor can collect before work begins, and a financially stable contractor has the credit to purchase materials without needing your money first. We recommend not paying the final balance until the job is complete and you are satisfied.
5. Refusing to Pull a Permit
Florida law requires a permit for a roof replacement. The permit ensures a county inspector verifies the work meets strict high-wind building codes. If a contractor asks you to pull the permit as the homeowner, they are likely unlicensed or have a suspended license—and you become legally responsible for the work.
6. No Proof of Insurance or Workers' Comp
Ask for a current Certificate of Insurance showing both general liability and workers' compensation coverage. If a worker is injured on your property and the contractor is uninsured, you can be held liable. A legitimate roofer emails or hands you the certificate directly from their carrier—never a photocopy or a screenshot.
7. Vague or Missing Written Contract
A handshake is not a contract. If the proposal doesn't list the exact shingle brand and model, underlayment type, flashing details, ventilation, cleanup, start date, and warranty terms in writing, you have no recourse when something goes wrong. "Standard materials" or "industry-standard installation" are not specifications—they're loopholes.
8. Unverifiable or No Reviews
A contractor with no Google reviews, a brand-new profile, or only reviews from out of state should raise suspicion. Look for a consistent history of local, verified reviews with photos and specifics. Be wary of review profiles that all appeared within the same week or that read like marketing copy.
9. Asking You to Sign Over Insurance Rights (AOB)
An Assignment of Benefits (AOB) hands control of your insurance claim—and the payout—directly to the contractor. Once signed, the insurer no longer deals with you, and disputes can end up in litigation that ties up your claim for months. Never sign an AOB without having an attorney review it, and be very cautious of any contractor who insists on one.
10. No Manufacturer Warranty Registration
Quality shingle manufacturers (Atlas, Owens Corning, GAF, Polyglass) back their products with warranties that are only valid when the installer is certified and registers the roof. If a contractor can't register your warranty or won't put the manufacturer warranty in your name, you're left with no coverage when materials fail.
How to Verify Any Roofing Contractor in Florida
Before you hire, take 10 minutes to run these checks. They're free, they protect you, and any honest contractor will encourage you to do them.
Verify the License Number
Look up the contractor's license at myfloridalicense.com. A Florida State Certified Roofing Contractor license starts with "CCC." Confirm it's active, not suspended, and matches the business name on the contract.
Confirm Insurance Coverage
Request a Certificate of Insurance directly from the contractor's carrier showing general liability and workers' compensation. Call the insurer to confirm the policy is active and covers roofing work.
Check the Local Better Business Bureau
Look up the business at bbb.org. Pay attention to the rating, how long the business has been accredited, and how complaints were resolved—not just whether complaints exist.
Read the Permit & Contract
Confirm the contractor—not you—pulls the permit, and that the contract specifies materials, scope, timeline, payment schedule, and warranty in writing. Never sign anything with blank spaces or "to be determined" terms.
The True Grit Standard of Trust
We believe in complete transparency and earning your business the right way. Here is what you should expect from a reputable Northwest Florida roofing contractor:
Verified Licensing
We are fully licensed in the State of Florida (CCC1337434) and carry comprehensive liability and workers' compensation insurance.
Local Reputation
We live and work in Pensacola. Our 5-star Google reviews come from your neighbors across Escambia and Santa Rosa counties.
Detailed Contracts
Everything is put in writing—from the exact shingle brand and color to the cleanup process and warranty details. No hidden fees.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it illegal for a contractor to pay my deductible in Florida?
Yes. Under Florida Statute 817.234, offering to pay, waive, or absorb an insurance deductible is insurance fraud—a third-degree felony. Any contractor who suggests it is committing a crime and is likely cutting corners elsewhere.
What should be in a roofing contract before I sign?
At minimum: the exact shingle brand and model, underlayment and flashing type, ventilation plan, total price, payment schedule, start and completion dates, cleanup terms, and both the workmanship and manufacturer warranty details. Never sign a contract with blank fields.
How much deposit is reasonable for a roof replacement?
Florida law restricts advance payments. A modest deposit to schedule and order materials is standard, but you should never pay the full amount upfront. Hold the final payment until the job is complete, the site is cleaned up, and you're satisfied.
What is an AOB and why should I be careful?
An Assignment of Benefits transfers your insurance claim rights to the contractor. Once signed, the insurer deals with the contractor—not you—and disputes can lead to litigation that delays your claim for months. Never sign one without legal review.
How do I know if a contractor is actually licensed?
Look up the license number at myfloridalicense.com. A Florida State Certified Roofing Contractor's license begins with 'CCC.' Confirm it's active and matches the business name on your contract.
Why does True Grit Roofing pull the permit for me?
Because Florida law requires the licensed contractor to pull the permit for a roof replacement. The permit triggers a county inspection that verifies the work meets high-wind building codes—protecting you and ensuring the job is done to code.
Hire With Confidence
Don't risk your home to the lowest bidder or an out-of-town chaser. Work with a local team that stands behind every roof we build.
Need a Professional Opinion?
Stop guessing about the condition of your roof. Get a free, comprehensive inspection with full photo documentation.